Imported powder is getting expensive or unavailable. How should I evaluate a domestic alternative?
Start with risk, not performance. List what could go wrong before you discuss specifications.
Four steps. First, lock down the critical parameters: identify the two or three properties that actually drive performance in your formula, such as oil absorption, D50, surface area or treatment type, and treat everything else as secondary. Second, compare like with like: require the domestic sample to be tested by the same method and ignore catalogue numbers, because data from different test conditions is not comparable. Third, run a bench trial replacing only that one powder at 50%, 75% and 100% substitution, measuring viscosity, stability, color difference and skin feel. Fourth, run accelerated stability for three months at 40 °C plus light exposure, watching for separation, color drift and pH shift.
Two things people skip. Documentation cannot be waived: if the domestic alternative cannot supply equivalently complete COA, MSDS and REACH declarations, EU and US customers will not accept it no matter how good the performance is. And batch consistency is usually where imports actually win, not on single-batch specs but on low variation, so request data from three to five consecutive lots and look at the spread.