Inorganic pigment or organic lake — how do I decide?
By the shade you need and by the regulatory route you can accept, not by preference.
Inorganic pigments (iron oxides, ultramarine, chromium oxide) are mineral, opaque, light-stable and cheap per unit of colour. They cover the earth tones and the whites, and they are the default in foundation and blush. Organic lakes (D&C and FD&C type) give the bright reds, yellows and blues that inorganics cannot reach, but they are dyes laid on a substrate, so they are less opaque, less light-stable, and their permitted use varies more between markets.
Our range splits exactly along that line: iron oxides and ultramarine under Inorganic, the lake series under Organic. If a shade can be hit with an inorganic, hit it with an inorganic.