Why does the colour not shift in my formula?
Usually because the particle is fully wetted and stays wetted, so there is no change in its local environment to trigger the shift.
The effect depends on the particle experiencing a change — typically moisture or pH — when the product is applied. In a heavily wetting base, or one where the water activity is already high and constant, the particle is at equilibrium from the moment it is mixed in and there is nothing left to trigger.
Check three things in this order: is the series right for the emulsion type; is the base wetting the particle too early; and is the loading high enough to be visible. The third is the most common and the easiest to fix.