Why does my mineral sunscreen pill or roll up?
Pilling is a film problem, not a pigment problem, and it usually has one of three causes.
The first is an incompatibility between the sunscreen film and the product applied underneath. A mineral sunscreen built on a W/O emulsion sits on top of a water-based serum, and the two films shear against each other as they are rubbed. If your test panel applies a moisturiser first, that is where to look.
The second is too high a solids loading with too little elastomer or oil to bind it. A high ZnO/TiO2 system with 25%+ solids has a lot of powder at the surface, and powder that is not held in the film rolls into pills.
The third is application — rubbing a thick mineral film too long. It sets, then breaks up.
The fixes follow: reduce solids or add a film former, add 1–3% of a spherical filler or boron nitride to improve slip and reduce the drag that causes over-rubbing, and test the product over the actual skincare routine your customers use.