Why are formulators moving away from bismuth oxychloride?
Bismuth oxychloride was once the workhorse for pearlescent effects, with strong lustre and good coverage, but photostability is its unavoidable weakness: it darkens and greys under UV and strong light, so products containing it often show shade drift over shelf life, especially in pale shades.
The usual replacement is synthetic fluorphlogopite or mica-based pearlescent pigments, which are slightly softer in lustre but far more stable. If the strong bismuth lustre must be kept, restrict it to packaging areas that are not light-exposed and validate photostability thoroughly.