A batch came out off-shade. Is it the slurry or my formula?
Check in this order: the container, the batch record, then the formula.
First the container. A high-loading slurry separates, and the top layer is carrier-rich while the bottom is pigment-rich. If the drum was not rolled before dispensing, the first portion out is not the same colour as the last. This is the most common cause and costs nothing to rule out.
Second the batch record: was the slurry weighed to the same precision, and was the dispersion time the same? A batch mixed for five minutes instead of fifteen reads differently in a thin film even with identical weights.
Third the formula: has the oil phase changed? A carrier swap or an emollient change alters how the pigment develops.
If all three are clean, ask for the retained sample of the slurry lot and compare it against your batch in a side-by-side drawdown.