Shine appears four hours in. Which powder do I change first?
Four hours is the classic signature of insufficient absorption capacity rather than insufficient speed. A speed problem shows up at one to two hours. So start by adding capacity, not by reaching for a smaller-pore grade.
Step one, confirm it. Compare shine area at one hour and at four. Little at one hour but obvious at four means capacity; heavy at one hour means speed, and that is when you move to small pores. Step two, add capacity: raise the large-pore grade (absorption above 200 g/100 g) by 30-50%, for example 3% to 4-4.5%. That usually buys 1.5-2 hours. Step three, if new problems appear such as tightness or a suffocating feel, absorption has overshot; switch to a grade that keeps its structure after absorbing, or add platelets to share the load. Step four, if capacity is adequate and shine still arrives at four hours, look at the oil content. Formula oils are dragged to the surface by sebum and form a sheen that no powder can absorb. Cutting total oil by 2-3%, or moving to oils with lower spread, usually does more than adding powder.
One factor that gets missed is film former. A powder layer without film support shifts and thins under friction, and the thin spots shine first. Adding 1-2% film former evens out the layer and costs less than more powder.
When not to touch the formula: if shine concentrates on the T-zone while the cheeks stay normal, that is sebum distribution, and zone application beats reformulation. If the user's skin care includes high-oil products such as rich cream or sunscreen, the shine may come from skin care rather than makeup.
Run the diagnostic in this order: speed or capacity, then scaffold, then oil content, then film. Change one variable and measure once before moving on.