Can powder choice stop touch-ups from caking and piling?
Yes, but first separate the causes. In most cases the powder is not the problem; the first layer is already saturated with oil.
Cause one, saturation. Four hours in, the powder has absorbed all the sebum it can hold and each particle is wrapped in oil. A fresh layer sticks to that oil film and builds into visible patches. Blotting before reapplication is a habit issue, but the formula can help by raising capacity so saturation arrives later.
Cause two, particle size. Touch-up powder sits on top of an existing layer, and coarse particles read as grit and pile-up, while fine powder at D50 5-8 microns blends in. Products meant for touch-ups should lean fine.
Cause three, particle surface. Untreated or strongly hydrophilic powder clumps where it meets the oil-water mixture on skin, producing small bumps. Hydrophobically treated powder spreads better over an oil film and does not clump when layered.
Three formula moves follow: fine particle size at D50 5-8 microns with a wide distribution so fines fill the gaps, a hydrophobic treatment, and 10-20% platelet powder to improve glide during layering.
There is also a design approach: build high capacity into a thin layer. A thin layer that holds six hours cuts the number of touch-ups, which removes the caking opportunity at the source. Many long-wear loose powders follow exactly this path.
One caution: caking at touch-up is sometimes a format problem rather than a formula problem. A pressed compact also gives controlled dosing, while loose powder is easy to over-apply. If complaints cluster around touch-up caking, check the format and the usage instructions before reformulating.