Oil-based or water-based slurry — what decides it?
The continuous phase of your finished emulsion, and nothing else. Put a water-based slurry into an anhydrous base and it will not incorporate; put an oil-based one into a gel and the same thing happens.
Beyond that: water-based slurries suit cushion foundation, liquid foundation, gel liner, nail polish and any aqueous system, and they give a lighter, less greasy feel. Oil-based slurries suit lipstick, lip gloss and anhydrous systems, and they give better wear and water resistance.
If you make both, you need both, and the pigment content differs — water-based runs lower, at 20–65%, because a water carrier with a high pigment load becomes unstable.