The bulk shipment does not perform like the sample we approved. Where do we start?
Four checks, in order — most issues are found before the fourth.
1. Same specification: grade, surface treatment type and coating level, particle size band. One difference changes the hand feel. 2. Formula changes: new lot of base oil, adjusted thickener system, substituted dispersant. 3. Process parameters: dispersion tip speed, time, temperature. After scale-up, shear energy is often lower than in the lab. 4. Dosage: lab trials are often dosed "a few drops per 100 g"; at scale the weighing error scales with it.
Send the bulk retention sample together with the original lab sample. We run a parallel comparison on particle size, whiteness, oil absorption and dispersibility, and the index that diverges identifies the cause.