Our incoming test flagged abnormal microbiology or heavy metals. Does the whole batch have to be scrapped?
Establish whether the finding holds before deciding on disposition.
Three things to confirm: whether sampling was representative (multi-point, avoiding the surface layer), whether the test method matches the standard behind the limit, and whether the limit was taken for the correct application (EU 1223/2009 or the Chinese Safety and Technical Standards for Cosmetics).
The first action is quarantine, not disposal: store the batch separately, do not feed it, do not blend it, and run a retest plus extended testing on the retention sample. If the exceedance is confirmed, it goes through the quality complaint process and we trace all downstream shipments of that batch by batch number.
One hard rule: do not "dilute" an abnormal batch with a conforming one. Afterwards neither batch is traceable, and neither will pass acceptance.