Is grittiness in lip mud caused by coarse powder?
Check dispersion before blaming particle size. In practice about seven out of ten "gritty" complaints turn out to be agglomerates, and an agglomerate behaves like a particle several times larger than the primary powder.
Three checks. First, grind gauge. If the reading is clearly above the D90 of the coarsest powder in the formula, it is agglomeration; if the reading sits near the D90 and it still feels gritty, the primary powder may genuinely be coarse. Second, the dispersion process. Lip mud usually runs a three-roll mill or bead mill; too few passes, high roll temperature or fast feed all leave unopened agglomerates. A quick test: run the same batch through two more passes and re-measure fineness and feel — a clear improvement means dispersion. Third, surface treatment and compatibility. A lip system is an anhydrous oil base; if the powder is not hydrophobically treated, wetting is poor, interfacial tension is high, and mechanical force alone will not open the agglomerate. Switching to a treated grade (SI or AS) is usually more effective than grinding finer.
If the primary powder really is too coarse, mind the trade-off: a finer particle size raises oil absorption, so the stick dries out and emphasises lip lines, and the colorant's opacity changes too. Adjust the oil phase at the same time.
One detail worth briefing the panel on: colorant agglomerates and base agglomerates feel different. Colorant shows up as specks or streaks, base as sandiness. Getting the person running the trial to describe which one they feel saves half the investigation.