How should powder differ between oily and dry skin formulas?
The two logics are close to opposite. One oil-control platform cannot serve both skin types without leaving one side unhappy.
For oily skin: high absorption with porous silica at 5-8%, mostly large pore, plus about 2% small pore for speed; platelet powder at 30-40% as a scaffold against collapse; oil phase held low at 2-4%; film former at 2-3% against rub-off. Particle size can run slightly coarse at D50 8-12 microns, since coarser particles carry more open volume and breathe better, which matters for comedogenic risk.
For dry skin: low absorption with porous silica at 1-3% or none at all; fine particles at D50 5-8 microns for better conformity; platelet powder at 35-45% for soft focus and skin affinity; oil phase at 6-10% to keep comfort; film former at 1-2%. What dry skin usually wants is no shine rather than oil removal, so low absorption plus high platelet content is sufficient and a large dose of porous powder is unnecessary.
What happens when the grades are swapped: a dry-skin customer on an oily-skin formula reports tightness, flaking after two hours and every fine line visible. An oily-skin customer on a dry-skin formula shines at four hours and goes patchy at six. Both complaints are grade mismatches at the formula level, not bad formulas.
One practical note for building two SKUs from one line: change the oil system and the particle size together, not just the powder dose. Versions that differ only in powder level usually test the same and customers report no difference.
For combination skin, either apply by zone or pick the middle grade: porous silica 3-4%, oil 4-6%, platelet 35%. The middle grade is not optimal for either extreme but is the practical compromise for combination skin.
If your customers cluster in one skin type, weigh climate alongside it, humid heat against dry cold, and set the grade for both variables rather than issuing one universal formula.