Is R457 the same figure as CIE whiteness, and can I compare them?
Whiteness is a convention, not a number. Comparing values from different conventions gives a wrong answer.
Two dominate. R457, also called ISO brightness, measures reflectance in the blue at 457 nm and is standard in paper and filler industries. CIE whiteness is derived from L*a*b* under ASTM E313 and is standard in coatings and plastics. The same talc can read 94 as R457 and 88 as CIE whiteness; the difference is the algorithm, not the material.
Three variables decide whether two numbers can be compared at all. Instrument and illuminant: D65/2° is the common basis, and a different illuminant moves the figure. Sample preparation: a pressed disc and a loose powder bed differ substantially, because the loose bed has a shorter path length and reads lower — two to four points on the same grade. And fluorescence: mineral powders generally contain no optical brightener, but a blended product or a treatment system can introduce one.
For purchasing, confirm four things: which standard, which illuminant and observer, how the sample is prepared, and whether the figure is a single reading or a mean. A supplier who can answer all four has traceable data; one who replies whiteness 95 usually cannot reconstruct how it was obtained.
One distinction to keep separate: whiteness is not opacity. A high whiteness figure does not mean the powder hides anything. Opacity comes from refractive index contrast and particle size — titanium dioxide hides because of its refractive index, and no whiteness value turns talc into a hiding powder.